Christian Foundations of America

Primary Source Verification | Truth Carriers Academy

Student Name:

Date Started:

HOW TO USE - Truth Carriers Learning Method (6 Rs)

RECEIVE (read), REFLECT (answer), RECALL (close book, write from memory), RECITE (teach someone), REVIEW (spaced repetition), RESPOND (apply).

"Blessed is the nation whose Elohim is Yahuah." — Psalm 33:12

About This Workbook:
This workbook presents PRIMARY SOURCES and lets facts speak. We acknowledge:
Our goal: Teach students to verify sources, not repeat propaganda.
📖 Note on Sacred Names:
In this workbook, historical quotes preserve the original language (using "God," "Lord," "Jesus Christ" as written by the Founders). This is authentic documentation. However, when referring to the Almighty in our own commentary, we use the sacred names Yahuah (יהוה - the Father), Yahusha (the Son), and Elohim (Mighty One). The Founders, influenced by Christianity's compromised translations, used substitute titles instead of the sacred name revealed in Exodus 3:14-15. We honor both historical accuracy and biblical truth.

Table of Contents

  1. The Founding Documents - What They Actually Say
  2. George Washington - Verified vs. Fabricated Quotes
  3. The Founders' Actual Beliefs (Primary Sources Only)
  4. State Constitutions - Religious Tests Required
  5. The Great Awakening's Political Influence
  6. Christianity's Role in Revolution
  7. Religious Demographics in 1776
  8. Myth vs. Reality - Both Sides Examined

Lesson 1: The Founding Documents - What They Actually Say

Declaration of Independence - Four God References

The Declaration of Independence (July 4, 1776) contains precisely four references to a divine being:

Reference 1 — "Nature's God" (opening paragraph):
"...the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them..."
Reference 2 — "Creator" (second paragraph):
"...that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights..."
Reference 3 — "Supreme Judge" (concluding section):
"...appealing to the Supreme Judge of the world for the rectitude of our intentions..."
Reference 4 — "Divine Providence" (final sentence):
"...with a firm reliance on the protection of divine Providence, we mutually pledge to each other our Lives, our Fortunes and our sacred Honor."
Scholarly Note: These terms—"Nature's God," "Creator," "Supreme Judge," "Providence"—were compatible with BOTH Christian orthodoxy AND Enlightenment Deism. This ambiguity was likely intentional, allowing broad acceptance among delegates with diverse religious views.

The Constitution's Notable Silence on God

The U.S. Constitution (September 17, 1787) contains NO reference to God, Jesus Christ, or Christianity in its operative text.

Article VI, Clause 3 — "No Religious Test" Clause:
"...but no religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States." [U.S. Constitution, Article VI]

Revolutionary context: When the Constitution was ratified, nine of thirteen states still required religious tests for office. The federal prohibition set a new standard.

First Amendment Religion Clauses

First Amendment (December 15, 1791):
"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof..." [Bill of Rights, First Amendment]

Critical context: The First Amendment originally applied ONLY to the federal government. Massachusetts maintained its Congregationalist establishment until 1833—the last state to disestablish.

Fill-in-the-Blank Questions

1. The Declaration of Independence contains exactly references to a divine being.

2. The U.S. Constitution contains references to God or Jesus Christ.

3. Article VI states that no religious shall ever be required for office.

4. When the Constitution was ratified, of thirteen states still required religious tests.

5. The last state to disestablish its church was in 1833.

True or False

— The Constitution mentions Jesus Christ by name.
— The First Amendment originally applied to state governments.

Primary Source Exercise

Read the Declaration of Independence and list the four references to a divine being:

📖 SCRIPTURE MEMORY: Psalm 33:12

"Blessed is the nation whose Elohim is Yahuah; and the people whom he hath chosen for his own inheritance."

📝 RECALL EXERCISE

Close this workbook. Write from memory: (1) The four divine references in the Declaration, (2) What the Constitution says about God, (3) What Article VI, Clause 3 prohibits.

🗣 TEACH-BACK CHALLENGE

Explain to someone the difference between the Declaration's God references and the Constitution's silence on religion.

Person I taught:

🎯 APPLICATION STEP

Lesson 2: George Washington - Verified vs. Fabricated Quotes

VERIFIED Quotes (With Primary Source Citations)

VERIFIED — Farewell Address (September 19, 1796):
"Of all the dispositions and habits which lead to political prosperity, Religion and morality are indispensable supports... let us with caution indulge the supposition, that morality can be maintained without religion." [Founders Online, National Archives]
VERIFIED — Letter to Hebrew Congregation (August 18, 1790):
The U.S. government "gives to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance." [Founders Online, National Archives]
VERIFIED — Thanksgiving Proclamation (October 3, 1789):
Washington acknowledged "the providence of Almighty God" and called for thanks for "civil and religious liberty." [Founders Online, National Archives]

FABRICATED Quote - DO NOT USE

FABRICATED — "It is impossible to rightly govern the world without God and the Bible"

Source Check: Mount Vernon's official website lists this as a "spurious quotation."
Fact Check: PolitiFact ruled FALSE: "no evidence he ever said this."
Origin: First appeared decades after Washington's death without documentation.

DO NOT ATTRIBUTE THIS QUOTE TO WASHINGTON.

Washington's Religious Practice - What Records Show

Fact Evidence
Served as vestryman Truro Parish (1762-1784), attended 23 of 35 vestry meetings
Church attendance Diaries show approximately once monthly
Did not take communion Multiple witnesses confirm he left before communion after the Revolution
Never mentioned "Jesus Christ" by name Not found in verified writings
Used deistic terms "Providence," "Grand Architect," "Supreme Being"
Scholarly Assessment: Historian David Holmes classifies Washington as a "theistic rationalist" or "warm Deist" who valued religion highly but may not have been an orthodox Christian.

Fill-in-the-Blank Questions

1. Washington said "Religion and are indispensable supports" in his Farewell Address.

2. The quote "impossible to rightly govern without God and the Bible" is listed as by Mount Vernon.

3. Washington left church before after the Revolutionary War.

4. Washington used terms like "Providence" and "Grand " for God.

5. Historians classify Washington as a "theistic " or "warm Deist."

Quote Verification Exercise

For each quote, identify if VERIFIED or FABRICATED:

— "Religion and morality are indispensable supports"
— "Impossible to rightly govern without God and the Bible"

Discussion Question

Why is it important to verify quotes before using them, even when they support our beliefs?

📖 SCRIPTURE MEMORY: Proverbs 12:22

"Lying lips are abomination to Yahuah: but they that deal truly are his delight."

📝 RECALL EXERCISE

Close this workbook. Write from memory: (1) Washington's verified quote about religion and morality, (2) The fabricated "Bible" quote, (3) Evidence that Washington may not have been orthodox.

🗣 TEACH-BACK CHALLENGE

Explain to someone why the "impossible to govern without God and Bible" quote should NOT be attributed to Washington.

Person I taught:

🎯 APPLICATION STEP

Lesson 3: The Founders' Actual Beliefs (Primary Sources Only)

John Adams - Unitarian Who Valued Religion

VERIFIED — Letter to Massachusetts Militia (October 11, 1798):
"Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious People. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other." [Founders Online, National Archives]

Adams' beliefs: Raised Congregationalist, rejected Calvinist doctrines and the Trinity, became a Unitarian. Called himself "a church going animal."

Thomas Jefferson - Creator of the "Jefferson Bible"

VERIFIED — Letter to Peter Carr (August 10, 1787):
"Fix reason firmly in her seat... Question with boldness even the existence of a god; because, if there be one, he must more approve of the homage of reason, than that of blindfolded fear." [Founders Online, National Archives]
The "Jefferson Bible" (1820):
Jefferson used razor and glue to extract moral teachings from the Gospels, removing all miracles, the virgin birth, and the resurrection. It ends with Jesus's burial—no resurrection. [Smithsonian National Museum of American History]

Benjamin Franklin - Believed in Providence, Doubted Christ's Divinity

VERIFIED — Letter to Ezra Stiles (March 9, 1790):
"I believe in one God, creator of the universe... As to Jesus of Nazareth... I have... some Doubts as to his Divinity: tho' it is a Question I do not dogmatise upon." [Founders Online, National Archives]
FABRICATED — "Beer is proof that God loves us"
Franklin never wrote this about beer. The actual quote referenced wine: "Behold the rain which descends from heaven upon our vineyards..."

Patrick Henry - An Actual Orthodox Christian

VERIFIED — Last Will and Testament (November 20, 1798):
"This is all the Inheritance I can give to my dear family, The religion of Christ can give them one which will make them rich indeed." [Red Hill Patrick Henry Memorial]
FABRICATED — "This great nation was founded... on the gospel of Jesus Christ"
This quote does NOT appear anywhere in Henry's recorded writings. First appeared in 1956 without citation.

Founders' Beliefs Summary

Founder Classification Key Evidence
George Washington Theistic Rationalist Avoided communion, used deistic terms
John Adams Unitarian Rejected Trinity, valued religion for society
Thomas Jefferson Deist Jefferson Bible removed miracles
Benjamin Franklin Deist/Theist Doubted Christ's divinity
Patrick Henry Orthodox Christian Explicit faith statements in will
Samuel Adams Orthodox Christian Devout Congregationalist

Fill-in-the-Blank Questions

1. John Adams said our Constitution was made only for a moral and people.

2. Jefferson created the "Jefferson " by removing miracles from the Gospels.

3. Franklin wrote that he had "some " about Christ's divinity.

4. Patrick Henry's will stated that the religion of could make his family rich.

5. John Adams became a , rejecting the Trinity.

Discussion Question

How should Christians respond to the fact that some founders held unorthodox religious views? Does this affect how we should view America's founding?

📖 SCRIPTURE MEMORY: 2 Timothy 2:15

"Study to shew thyself approved unto Elohim, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth."

📝 RECALL EXERCISE

Close this workbook. Write from memory: (1) Adams' verified quote about moral and religious people, (2) What Jefferson did to the Gospels, (3) Which founders were orthodox Christians.

🗣 TEACH-BACK CHALLENGE

Explain to someone the range of religious beliefs among the Founders, from Deist to orthodox Christian.

Person I taught:

🎯 APPLICATION STEP

Lesson 4: State Constitutions - Religious Tests Required

While the federal Constitution prohibited religious tests, original STATE constitutions tell a very different story.

Delaware (1776) - Trinitarian Oath Required

"I, A B, do profess faith in God the Father, and in Jesus Christ His only Son, and in the Holy Ghost, one God, blessed for evermore; and I do acknowledge the holy scriptures of the Old and New Testament to be given by divine inspiration." [Delaware Constitution of 1776]

Pennsylvania (1776) - Scripture Belief Required

"I do believe in one God, the Creator and Governor of the Universe, the rewarder of the good and the punisher of the wicked. And I do acknowledge the Scriptures of the Old and New Testament to be given by Divine inspiration." [Pennsylvania Constitution of 1776]

Massachusetts (1780) - Christian Declaration Required

"I, A. B., do declare, that I believe the Christian religion, and have a firm persuasion of its truth." [Massachusetts Constitution of 1780]

North Carolina (1776) - Protestants Only

"No person, who shall deny the being of God or the truth of the Protestant religion... shall be capable of holding any office or place of trust." [North Carolina Constitution of 1776]

When Were These Requirements Removed?

State Original Requirement Year Removed
Pennsylvania Belief in Scripture 1790
Delaware Trinitarian oath 1792
North Carolina Protestant requirement 1789 (changed to "Christian")
Massachusetts Christian declaration 1833
Maryland Belief in God 1961 (Supreme Court)
Key Distinction: The FEDERAL government was secular by design. The STATES maintained religious establishments for decades. Both facts are true and important.

Fill-in-the-Blank Questions

1. Delaware required a oath (belief in Father, Son, Holy Ghost).

2. North Carolina originally limited office to only.

3. Massachusetts was the last state to disestablish its church in .

4. Maryland's requirement wasn't removed until the struck it down in 1961.

5. The federal government was by design, while states maintained religious tests.

True or False

— All states immediately adopted the federal "no religious test" policy.
— Some states required belief in Scripture to hold office.

Discussion Question

Why do you think the federal government prohibited religious tests while states maintained them? What might this tell us about the founders' intentions?

📖 SCRIPTURE MEMORY: James 2:12

"So speak ye, and so do, as they that shall be judged by the law of liberty."

📝 RECALL EXERCISE

Close this workbook. Write from memory: (1) What Delaware's Trinitarian oath required, (2) Which states had Protestant-only requirements, (3) When the last state religious requirement was removed.

🗣 TEACH-BACK CHALLENGE

Explain to someone the difference between federal and state approaches to religion in early America.

Person I taught:

🎯 APPLICATION STEP

Lesson 5: The Great Awakening's Political Influence

What Was the Great Awakening?

The Great Awakening (1730s-1740s) was a massive religious revival that swept through the American colonies. Key preachers:

Political Effects of the Awakening

Effect How It Influenced Revolution
Individual liberty emphasis Personal relationship with God led to questioning traditional authority
Questioning of authority If church hierarchy could be questioned, so could political hierarchy
Unity across colonies Shared religious experience created inter-colonial bonds
Common man empowerment Gospel preached to all classes equally

Sermon as Political Tool

Samuel Davies - "The Curse of Cowardice" (1758):
This sermon argued that armed resistance against tyranny was justified. It helped shape the colonial mindset that would later support revolution. [Historical sermon records]

Fill-in-the-Blank Questions

1. The Great Awakening occurred during the s and 1740s.

2. George preached to crowds of 80,000+ colonists.

3. The Awakening emphasized individual with God.

4. Harry Hosier, called "Black Harry," was a preacher who influenced thousands.

5. The Awakening created across the colonies through shared religious experience.

Short Answer

How did questioning religious authority help prepare colonists to question political authority?

📖 SCRIPTURE MEMORY: John 8:36

"If the Son therefore shall make you free, ye shall be free indeed."

📝 RECALL EXERCISE

Close this workbook. Write from memory: (1) The three main Great Awakening preachers, (2) How the Awakening prepared colonists for Revolution, (3) The dates of the Great Awakening.

🗣 TEACH-BACK CHALLENGE

Explain to someone how the Great Awakening influenced the American Revolution.

Person I taught:

🎯 APPLICATION STEP

Lesson 6: Christianity's Role in Revolution

The "Black Regiment"

British called colonial clergy the "Black Regiment" because preachers wore black robes and were influential supporters of revolution. They:

Declaration's Theology

Key theological claim:
Rights come from the Creator—not from the king. This was a revolutionary concept that legitimized resistance against George III.

Colonial Support for Revolution

Group Approximate Support
Patriots (supported revolution) ~40-45%
Loyalists (opposed revolution) ~15-20%
Neutral/undecided ~35-45%

Note: About 2/3 of colonists who took a position supported revolution. Church attendance correlated with higher patriot support.

Fill-in-the-Blank Questions

1. British called colonial clergy the " Regiment."

2. Clergy debated 13 about when to obey or resist government.

3. The Declaration claims rights come from the , not the king.

4. About % of colonists were Patriots who supported revolution.

5. Election day promoted resistance theology.

Discussion Question

When is resistance to government justified according to biblical principles? How did colonists answer this question?

📖 SCRIPTURE MEMORY: Acts 5:29

"Then Peter and the other apostles answered and said, We ought to obey Elohim rather than men."

📝 RECALL EXERCISE

Close this workbook. Write from memory: (1) Why clergy were called the "Black Regiment," (2) What Romans 13 debate was about, (3) Percentages of Patriots vs. Loyalists.

🗣 TEACH-BACK CHALLENGE

Explain to someone how colonial preachers used the Bible to justify revolution against tyranny.

Person I taught:

🎯 APPLICATION STEP

Lesson 7: Religious Demographics in 1776

Church Affiliation in Colonial America

Overall: Approximately 75% of the population was affiliated with churches in 1776.

Denominational Breakdown

Denomination Percentage
Congregationalist ~20%
Presbyterian ~19%
Baptist ~17%
Anglican/Episcopal ~16%
Other (Quaker, Lutheran, Reformed, etc.) ~28%

Regional Variations

Region Church Affiliation Dominant Tradition
New England ~85%+ Congregationalist (Puritan legacy)
Middle Colonies ~65% Religious diversity
Southern Colonies ~60% Anglican (often nominal)
Important Distinction: Church affiliation ≠ personal salvation. Nominal Christianity was widespread. Being on a church roll did not necessarily mean genuine faith.

Fill-in-the-Blank Questions

1. Approximately % of the colonial population was affiliated with churches.

2. The largest denomination was at about 20%.

3. New England had the highest church affiliation at %+.

4. The Southern colonies were dominated by the church.

5. Church affiliation does not necessarily equal personal .

True or False

— Everyone on a church roll in 1776 was a genuine born-again believer.
— American culture in 1776 was predominantly Christian.

📖 SCRIPTURE MEMORY: Matthew 7:14

"Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it."

📝 RECALL EXERCISE

Close this workbook. Write from memory: (1) The percentage of church affiliation in 1776, (2) The four largest denominations, (3) The difference between church affiliation and salvation.

🗣 TEACH-BACK CHALLENGE

Explain to someone the religious demographics of colonial America and what they do/don't prove.

Person I taught:

🎯 APPLICATION STEP

Lesson 8: Myth vs. Reality - Both Sides Examined

Myth 1: "America Was Founded as a Christian Nation"

Partial Truth: American CULTURE was largely Christian (75% church affiliation).
But: The FEDERAL GOVERNMENT was explicitly secular—no religious tests, no established church, no mention of Christ in the Constitution.

Myth 2: "The Founders Were All Deists or Atheists"

Partial Truth: Some founders (Jefferson, Franklin) held Deist or unorthodox views.
But: Others (Patrick Henry, Samuel Adams, John Jay) were orthodox Christians. The founders were religiously DIVERSE.

Myth 3: "Treaty of Tripoli Doesn't Count"

Treaty of Tripoli, Article 11 (1797):
"As the government of the United States of America is not in any sense founded on the Christian Religion..." [Ratified unanimously by Senate, signed by President Adams]
Context: This was diplomatic language to distinguish America from European "Christian nations" that had centuries of conflict with Islamic states. It referred to the FEDERAL GOVERNMENT structure, not American culture.

Both perspectives have merit: The treaty was ratified without objection, but it was addressing a specific diplomatic purpose.

The Balanced Conclusion

Claim Accurate Assessment
American culture was Christian TRUE - 75% church affiliation, Christian values dominant
Federal government was secular TRUE - No religious tests, no establishment
All founders were Christians FALSE - Range from orthodox to Deist
All founders were Deists FALSE - Many were orthodox Christians
State governments were secular FALSE - Many had religious establishments

Fill-in-the-Blank Questions

1. American CULTURE was largely , but the federal government was secular.

2. The Treaty of Tripoli says America was "not in any sense founded on the Religion."

3. The founders were religiously , ranging from orthodox to Deist.

4. State governments often had religious unlike the federal government.

5. The phrase "separation of church and state" comes from Jefferson's , not the Constitution.

Final Discussion

After studying the primary sources, how would YOU describe America's religious founding? What nuances are important to include?

📖 SCRIPTURE MEMORY: John 8:32

"And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free."

📝 RECALL EXERCISE

Close this workbook. Write from memory: (1) The balanced assessment of "Christian nation" claim, (2) What the Treaty of Tripoli says, (3) Three verified vs. fabricated facts about the Founders.

🗣 TEACH-BACK CHALLENGE

Explain to someone the nuanced truth about America's religious founding—avoiding both extremes.

Person I taught:

🎯 APPLICATION STEP

SPACED REVIEW TRACKER

LessonDoneD1D3D7D21D60
1. Founding Documents
2. Founders' Beliefs
3. Colonial Charters
4. Education History
5. First Amendment
6. Court Decisions
7. Revivals Impact
8. Church & State

Answer Key

Lesson 1

Fill-in-the-Blank: 1. four 2. zero/no 3. test 4. nine 5. Massachusetts

True/False: 1. False 2. False

Lesson 2

Fill-in-the-Blank: 1. morality 2. spurious/fabricated 3. communion 4. Architect 5. rationalist

Quote Verification: 1. Verified 2. Fabricated

Lesson 3

Fill-in-the-Blank: 1. religious 2. Bible 3. Doubts 4. Christ 5. Unitarian

Lesson 4

Fill-in-the-Blank: 1. Trinitarian 2. Protestants 3. 1833 4. Supreme Court 5. secular

True/False: 1. False 2. True

Lesson 5

Fill-in-the-Blank: 1. 1730 2. Whitefield 3. relationship 4. Black 5. unity

Lesson 6

Fill-in-the-Blank: 1. Black 2. Romans 3. Creator 4. 40-45 5. sermons

Lesson 7

Fill-in-the-Blank: 1. 75 2. Congregationalist 3. 85 4. Anglican 5. salvation

True/False: 1. False 2. True

Lesson 8

Fill-in-the-Blank: 1. Christian 2. Christian 3. diverse 4. establishments 5. letter

Progress Saved